When you decide to learn piano, one of the first choices you’ll face is also one of the most consequential: do you start with sheet music and traditional technique, or do you start with chords? The answer shapes everything — how fast you progress, what music you can play, and whether you’ll still be practicing three months from now.
Here’s an honest comparison of both approaches, with no agenda toward either.
The Traditional Method: What It Is and Who It’s For
The traditional approach to piano is the one most people imagine when they think of piano lessons: a teacher, a book of graded pieces, scales practiced daily, and a slow, methodical progression through increasingly complex classical repertoire.
You start by learning to read notation. Then scales. Then simple pieces chosen from a pedagogical series. Over months and years, the pieces get more complex and the technique more refined.
This method has real strengths. It builds comprehensive technique. It develops music reading fluency. It creates a foundation that makes advanced classical repertoire accessible. And for people who want to play classical music at a serious level, it’s still the right path.
Its weakness — for most adult beginners — is time. Months can pass before you’re playing anything that sounds like music you’d want to listen to. That gap between starting and satisfaction kills motivation for a lot of adults who would have loved the piano if they’d just gotten to real music faster.
The Chord Method: What It Is and Who It’s For
The chord method starts from a completely different premise: instead of learning to read notation before you play, you learn to play first — specifically, the chords and rhythm patterns that underpin the music you already love.
From day one, you’re working with actual songs. You learn a handful of chord shapes, a simple strumming or accompaniment pattern, and within days you’re playing something recognizable. Theory is introduced alongside what you’re playing, not as a prerequisite.
The strengths of this approach for adult beginners are significant. You get to real music fast. Motivation stays high because you’re immediately playing things that sound good. The chord vocabulary you build works across genres — pop, jazz, blues, folk, ballads. And you develop genuine musical instinct about how songs are structured, which makes learning new music faster over time.
Which Method Produces Faster Results?
For raw speed to playing recognizable music: the chord method wins clearly. Most chord-method students are playing through complete songs within 2–3 weeks. Most traditional-method beginners take 2–4 months to reach an equivalent milestone.
For long-term technical development at the highest levels: the traditional method still dominates. Concert-level classical playing requires the kind of formal technique that chord-based methods don’t fully develop on their own.
For most adult learners — who want to play songs they love, sound good at home or socially, and keep practicing long enough to actually get good — the chord method wins on the grounds that matter most: it keeps you at the piano.
Can You Learn Both?
Yes, and this is actually what the best self-study courses do. Pianoforall starts with rhythm and chord patterns (getting you playing immediately), then introduces more formal technique, reading, scales, and classical repertoire later in the curriculum. By that point you have enough musical understanding that the formal skills come much more naturally.
The Best of Both Methods
Pianoforall is built on the chord method for the early stages — getting you playing real music immediately — then transitions into formal technique, sight reading, and classical piano as you advance. You end up with a complete musical education, delivered in the most motivating sequence possible.
The Decision: Which Should You Choose?
Start with the chord method if: you’re an adult beginner who wants to play real music quickly, you’re self-teaching, you want to play pop/jazz/blues/folk, or you’ve tried traditional methods before and quit.
Start with the traditional method if: your primary goal from day one is classical repertoire, you have access to a great teacher, or you’re learning with a child who has time for the longer initial curve.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the chord method cheating?
No. Chord-based playing is a completely legitimate musical skill used by professional musicians across virtually every genre outside of classical music. Jazz musicians, pop pianists, session players — most of them lead with chord knowledge, not sheet music reading.
Can you become a good pianist using the chord method?
Absolutely. The chord method builds genuine musicianship, harmonic understanding, and playing facility. Many accomplished pianists primarily use chord-based techniques.
Which method is better for learning to play songs?
The chord method is significantly faster for learning to play contemporary songs. For classical pieces that require reading from notation, the traditional method builds the necessary reading skills faster.
Looking for a comprehensive piano course? Read a chord-based course we reviewed — 10 eBooks with audio and video for a one-time price.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in.