YouTube has millions of free piano tutorials. Pianoforall costs $49. So why would anyone pay when there’s so much available for free? The answer matters — and it’s not what most people expect when they first start out.
What YouTube does well
YouTube is genuinely excellent for specific things: learning a single song you want to play, watching technique demonstrations, exploring a style or concept you’re curious about, or supplementing a course you’re already following. For one-off questions and short-form learning, it’s unbeatable — and free.
Channels like PianoTV, Piano Lessons On The Web, and Rousseau offer high-quality content. If you want to learn how to play “Let It Be” or understand how to voice a dominant seventh chord, YouTube is a perfectly good place to look.
Where YouTube falls short
The problem with YouTube as a primary learning method is structure. There isn’t any. You watch a tutorial for one song, then another, then a theory video that references things you haven’t learned yet, then a technique video that assumes skills you don’t have. You can spend hours watching piano content and make almost no actual progress, because you’re collecting information rather than building a skill.
Piano is a cumulative skill. Lesson 10 depends on what you learned in lessons 1–9. Lesson 20 depends on 1–19. Without a sequential progression, gaps appear — and gaps compound. Something that seemed like a minor hole in your knowledge at month 2 becomes a real obstacle at month 6.
What Pianoforall does differently
Pianoforall is a structured curriculum — 10 books, 300+ video lessons — that builds from a starting point to an advanced level in a deliberate sequence. Each lesson builds on the last. There are no gaps. You always know what comes next.
It also has a distinct method: chord-based, rhythm-first piano that gets you playing real songs immediately while building theory and technique progressively. This isn’t something YouTube tutorials provide — they’re optimized for views, not for your long-term development.
The real cost of free
Free isn’t actually free if it takes you three times as long to reach your goals — or if you plateau and give up because you can’t figure out what to work on next. The cost of a structured course isn’t just money; it’s also time saved, frustration avoided, and skills built correctly from the start.
Most people who use Pianoforall tried YouTube first. The $49 one-time price becomes easy to justify once you experience the difference a real progression makes.
See what’s inside Pianoforall →
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.